Top 5 Graphic Novel Underdogs We Love

Graphic novels are a vibrant, diverse storytelling medium, ranging from blockbuster hits to hidden gems that quietly capture the hearts of readers. While some titles dominate the spotlight, there are countless underrated works—underdogs—that deserve more recognition. These novels often feature unique artwork, compelling characters, and imaginative narratives that push the boundaries of the medium. Here’s a look at five graphic novels underdogs we absolutely love.

Nimona by Noelle Stevenson

Before it gained wider acclaim, Nimona started as an indie webcomic that charmed readers with its quirky humor and heartfelt story. It follows a shapeshifter named Nimona and her morally ambiguous mentor, Ballister Blackheart, as they navigate a world of heroes, villains, and complicated friendships. Stevenson’s expressive art and witty dialogue make this story both playful and poignant. The graphic novel shines with themes of loyalty, identity, and challenging the status quo, proving that underdog titles can leave a lasting impact.

Daytripper by Fábio Moon and Gabriel Bá

Daytripper is a meditation on life, love, and the passage of time. The story follows Brás de Oliva Domingos, an obituary writer whose life is explored through pivotal moments, both big and small. Moon and Bá craft a narrative that’s as much about self-discovery as it is about mortality, with stunning black-and-white illustrations that enhance the emotional resonance. Though it doesn’t always make mainstream “must-read” lists, Daytripper remains an unforgettable, heartfelt journey that deserves broader attention.

Locke & Key by Joe Hill and Gabriel Rodríguez

Before becoming a popular TV adaptation, Locke & Key quietly captivated fans of supernatural horror and fantasy. The series follows the Locke family as they discover magical keys in their ancestral home, each granting unique powers—and each attracting danger. Joe Hill’s inventive storytelling and Rodríguez’s detailed, atmospheric artwork create a suspenseful and immersive reading experience. While not as mainstream as superhero titles, this graphic novel blends mystery, horror, and family drama in a way that hooks readers from the first page.

Sandman Mystery Theatre by Matt Wagner and Steven T. Seagle

This noir-inspired take on the classic Sandman character is often overlooked by casual readers, but it offers a compelling mix of crime, psychological intrigue, and social commentary. Set in the 1930s, it follows Wesley Dodds, a detective-turned-hero, navigating morally complex cases. Wagner and Seagle’s storytelling is nuanced and layered, blending suspense with historical detail. For fans of mystery and atmospheric graphic novels, Sandman Mystery Theatre is a hidden gem worth exploring.

Essex County by Jeff Lemire

Essex County is a tender, character-driven exploration of rural life, family, and loss. Lemire’s storytelling is intimate and deeply human, highlighting the quiet struggles and connections that define the characters’ lives. The hand-drawn art style adds warmth and authenticity to the narrative, making it a poignant reading experience. While it may not have the flashy appeal of mainstream superhero comics, Essex County earns its place as a profoundly moving underdog graphic novel.

Why We Love Graphic Novel Underdogs

Underrated graphic novels often take creative risks, explore unconventional stories, and showcase artistic innovation. They remind us that not all great storytelling comes from high-profile releases. These hidden gems allow readers to experience unique perspectives, emotional depth, and imaginative worlds that might otherwise go unnoticed.

For fans of the medium, exploring these underdogs is a way to expand horizons, discover new voices, and appreciate the artistry behind every panel. They prove that in the world of graphic novels, sometimes the most memorable stories come from the titles flying under the radar.

Whether it’s the heartwarming charm of Nimona, the philosophical reflection of Daytripper, or the suspenseful thrill of Locke & Key, these underdog graphic novels demonstrate the richness of the medium. They may not always dominate bestseller lists, but their storytelling, creativity, and artistry make them unforgettable.